What Can I Substitute for Half-And-Half?

Showing Australian names and measurements · change country in the menu

Swap for half-and-half: full-cream milk + thickened cream, 185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half. Verdict: straight swap

Three parts milk to one part cream lands at about 11–12% fat, so it matches half-and-half on richness, liquid, body and heat stability. Full details

Checked 25 October 2026 · Rankings aren't for sale

What's it doing in this dish?

You're adding a splash to coffee or tea and want it creamy without being heavy.

full-cream milk + thickened cream — 185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half
light cream — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half
barista oat milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

In coffee the job is richness and resisting curdling in the hot cup, so the milk-and-cream mix matches it most closely. Light cream does the same with a little more richness. Barista oat milk is the dairy-free choice because it is made to stay smooth in hot coffee, though it is leaner. Mix a jar of the milk-and-cream blend and keep it in the fridge so you are not measuring each cup.

You're stirring it into a pan sauce, creamy soup or chowder that will simmer and needs to stay smooth.

full-cream milk + thickened cream — 185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half
light cream — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half
evaporated milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Here heat stability and body matter as much as richness, because a low-fat liquid can split when it simmers or meets wine or tomato. All three keep enough fat or concentrated milk solids to hold together. Evaporated milk is especially sturdy in chowders and pasta bakes, but its cooked-milk taste and beige tint show in a pale, delicate sauce.

You're making a baked custard, quiche, bread-and-butter pudding or churned ice cream where the liquid has to set or freeze to a particular richness.

full-cream milk + thickened cream — 185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half
light cream — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half
evaporated milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

The fat level decides how firm and silky the set is, so you want something close to 10–12% fat. The milk-and-cream blend lands right there. Light cream sets a little richer and firmer, and evaporated milk gives good body in quiche but a slightly caramelised flavour in a plain sweet custard. Plain milk sets softer and wetter, so avoid it here.

You're adding it to pancake or muffin batter, mashed potato or scrambled eggs, where it mainly needs to be a slightly rich liquid.

full-cream milk + melted butter — 230 ml full-cream milk + 20 g melted butter for every 250 ml half-and-half
full-cream milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

In these dishes the main job is moisture, with richness as a bonus, and nothing is simmered long enough to curdle. Milk with melted butter brings the fat back up and the butter flavour suits mash and batters. Plain milk works too and the result is only a little leaner. Weigh the butter rather than spooning it, because an Australian tablespoon is 20 ml.

You're cooking a soup, curry or bake for someone who can't have dairy and need a rich liquid that won't split.

coconut milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half
barista oat milk — 250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Canned coconut milk has enough fat to cover richness and body and holds up when simmered, so it suits curries, pumpkin soup and dairy-free baking where a coconut taste is welcome. Barista oat milk is leaner and better kept to drinks or gentle dishes, because it lacks the fat that gives heat stability.

What Half-And-Half does in a recipe

fat & richness · primary — At roughly 10–18% fat it carries about three to four times the fat of milk, giving coffee, sauces and custards a rounder, creamier taste without the heaviness of cream.
moisture · primary — It is about 80% water, so in most recipes it is the main liquid as well as the dairy element.
body & mouthfeel · secondary — The extra fat and milk solids make it pour and coat a spoon slightly thicker than milk, which gives soups, scrambled eggs and baked custards a smoother, fuller texture.
stability in heat · secondary — The higher fat content protects the milk proteins, so it is less likely than milk to curdle when simmered in a sauce or poured into hot coffee.

Every substitute, ranked

Substitute	Amount	Verdict
full-cream milk + thickened cream	185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half	Straight swap
light cream	250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half	Straight swap
full-cream milk + melted butter	230 ml full-cream milk + 20 g melted butter for every 250 ml half-and-half	One catch
evaporated milk	250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half	Close enough
full-cream milk	250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half	Close enough
coconut milk	250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half	Close enough
barista oat milk	250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half	Close enough

full-cream milk + thickened cream

Straight swap· probably in your pantry

185 ml full-cream milk + 65 ml thickened cream for every 250 ml half-and-half

Three parts milk to one part cream lands at about 11–12% fat, so it matches half-and-half on richness, liquid, body and heat stability.

Covers: fat & richness, moisture, body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Taste: Most people cannot pick the difference, though thickened cream can leave a faint gelatine or gum note that pure cream avoids.
Texture: Pours and coats a spoon much like half-and-half once stirred together.
Looks: Looks the same in coffee, sauces and custards.
Best for: coffee and tea, cream sauces and soups, baked custards and quiche

Gluten-freeNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

light cream

Straight swap

250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Light pouring cream has somewhat more fat than half-and-half, so it covers every role and simply makes the result a little richer.

Covers: fat & richness, moisture, body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Taste: Tastes slightly creamier and fuller than half-and-half.
Texture: A touch thicker, which you may notice in custards and soups.
Looks: Looks the same.
Best for: coffee, pan sauces, scrambled eggs

Gluten-freeNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

full-cream milk + melted butter

One catch· probably in your pantry

230 ml full-cream milk + 20 g melted butter for every 250 ml half-and-half

Butter tops milk up to roughly 10% fat, covering richness and liquid, but the butterfat is not emulsified in like cream and can separate unless the mix is warm and whisked.

The catch: Warm the milk, whisk in the melted unsalted butter and use it straight into a warm recipe; weigh the 20 g rather than spooning it, because an Australian tablespoon is 20 ml and will throw the amount out.

Covers: fat & richness, moisture
Misses: body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Taste: Has a noticeable buttery note, and salted butter will add salt.
Texture: Thinner than half-and-half, and fat can bead on the surface if it cools.
Looks: Small fat droplets may show on top of coffee or a cooled sauce.
Best for: mashed potato, baking batters, soups

Gluten-freeNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

evaporated milk

Close enough· probably in your pantry

250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Full-cream evaporated milk has concentrated milk solids and stays stable when heated, so it gives body and holds up in cooking, though it has a little less fat than half-and-half.

Covers: moisture, body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Misses: fat & richness
Taste: Adds a cooked, faintly caramelised milk flavour that shows in coffee and plain custards.
Texture: Similar body to half-and-half, slightly less rich on the tongue.
Looks: Has a slightly beige tint that can show in pale sauces.
Best for: soups and chowders, quiche, pasta bakes

Gluten-freeNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

full-cream milk

Close enough· probably in your pantry

250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Milk replaces the liquid but has only about a third of the fat, so richness, body and heat stability all drop.

The catch: In sauces, stir it in off the boil and keep it at a gentle simmer to lower the risk of curdling.

Covers: moisture
Misses: fat & richness, body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Taste: Noticeably leaner and less creamy.
Texture: Thinner, so custards set softer and soups feel lighter.
Looks: Coffee looks paler and greyer for the same amount added.
Best for: pancakes and muffins, scrambled eggs, everyday coffee

Gluten-freeNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

coconut milk

Close enough· probably in your pantry

250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Canned coconut milk has enough fat to cover richness and body and holds up when simmered, making it a dairy-free option for cooked dishes if you accept the coconut flavour.

The catch: If your can is very thick and creamy, thin it with water until it pours like milk before measuring.

Covers: fat & richness, moisture, body & mouthfeel, stability in heat
Taste: Clearly tastes of coconut, which suits curries and soups but not a classic cream sauce.
Texture: Similar richness, sometimes slightly grainy if the can has separated.
Looks: Bright white and very close in colour.
Best for: dairy-free soups, curries, dairy-free baking

Dairy-freeVeganGluten-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

barista oat milk

Close enough

250 ml for every 250 ml half-and-half

Barista oat milk is formulated to stay smooth in hot coffee and gives some body, but it is much lower in fat than half-and-half.

Covers: moisture, body & mouthfeel
Misses: fat & richness, stability in heat
Taste: Has a mild cereal sweetness instead of a dairy flavour.
Texture: Thinner and less rich, though smoother in coffee than regular oat milk.
Looks: Slightly more beige in coffee.
Best for: coffee and tea, dairy-free porridge

Dairy-freeVeganNut-free

Tried this swap? How did it work?

Commonly tried, but skip these

People reach for these, and they let you down.

skim milk

Skip it

People reach for it because it is the milk in the fridge, but with almost no fat it curdles easily in hot sauces, leaves custards weepy and soft, and makes cream-based dishes taste thin.

Tried this swap? How did it work?

sweetened condensed milk

Skip it

People confuse it with evaporated milk because the cans sit side by side, but the large amount of added sugar makes savoury sauces and soups inedibly sweet and causes baked custards and quiches to brown and burn.

Tried this swap? How did it work?

When to buy the real thing

You're making churned ice cream or a set custard and are tempted to use plain milk, skim milk or oat milk because it's what you have.
Instead: Make the half-and-half yourself by mixing three parts full-cream milk with one part cream, measured in millilitres, because the fat level controls how creamy the ice cream freezes and how firmly the custard sets.
The recipe expects half-and-half to whip into soft peaks or a topping.
Instead: Use cream with at least 35% fat, such as thickened cream, because half-and-half and every substitute on this page have too little fat to hold air.
A savoury recipe calls for half-and-half and the only can in the pantry is sweetened condensed milk.
Instead: Use full-cream milk, evaporated milk or the milk-and-butter mix instead, because condensed milk's sugar will make the dish taste like dessert and scorch in the oven.

Rescue a swap gone wrong

Your sauce or soup has turned grainy or split into flecks after you stirred in milk instead of half-and-half.

Why: Milk has too little fat to protect its proteins, so boiling, or acid from wine, lemon or tomato, made them clump.

Fix: Take the pan off the heat, whisk in a splash of cream, then blend briefly with a stick blender until smooth; next time add the milk off the boil and keep it at a gentle simmer.

You can see greasy beads or a yellow film on top of your coffee or sauce made with milk and melted butter.

Why: The butterfat is not emulsified into the milk the way it is in cream, so it separates as the mix cools or sits.

Fix: Rewarm the sauce and whisk hard or blend it to bring the fat back in; for coffee, whisk the milk and butter together while warm and use it straight away, or switch to the milk-and-cream mix.

Your baked custard or quiche came out soft, weepy or watery in the middle.

Why: Full-cream milk or skim milk has much less fat than half-and-half, so the custard sets more loosely and releases liquid.

Can't be fixed — next time: It can't be firmed up once baked, so serve it as it is; next time use three parts milk to one part cream, or light cream, and measure by millilitres rather than spoons.

Your savoury dish tastes sweet and has browned too much.

Why: Sweetened condensed milk was used instead of evaporated milk, and its added sugar sweetens the dish and caramelises in the heat.

Can't be fixed — next time: A sauce can be partly saved by diluting it with unsweetened milk or stock and adding salt or acid, but a baked quiche or custard can't be rescued; next time check that the can says evaporated milk.

Key numbers

Weight of 1 cup: 256 g per Australian cup (250 ml) · 246 g per US cup (240 ml)Spooned in and levelled. Compare other ingredients in cups to grams by ingredient.
Fat (US half-and-half): 10.5–18%Most US half-and-half sits near the bottom of this legal range, at about 10.5–12%.
Fat (Canadian half-and-half): 10%In Canada it is often labelled 10% cream.
Fat (UK half cream): at least 12%UK half cream is the closest product sold under a local name.
Water: about 80%The high water content is why milk-based mixes can stand in for it as the recipe liquid.
Protein: about 3%The protein level is close to milk, so the difference from milk comes almost entirely from fat.
Sugar (lactose): about 4%This is natural milk sugar only, so standard half-and-half is not sweetened.
Fat (Australian full-cream milk): about 3.4%Milk alone has roughly a third or less of the fat of half-and-half.
Fat (Australian thickened cream): at least 35%Cream has about three times the fat of half-and-half, which is why it is diluted with milk at about one part cream to three parts milk.

Differences between countries

Applies to Australia

Rarely sold as a ready-made product (Australia, New Zealand)

Half-and-half is not a standard supermarket line in Australia or New Zealand, so recipes that call for it usually mean you mix your own. Three parts full-cream milk to one part cream is the usual home blend.

Fat-free half-and-half is a labelling trap (United States)

US supermarkets sell a fat-free half-and-half made from skim milk with added sweeteners and thickeners. It has none of the fat that gives regular half-and-half its richness and curdle resistance, so it does not behave the same in sauces or custards.

Sold in pints, quarts and single-serve cups (United States)

US half-and-half comes in pint (about 473 ml) and quart (about 946 ml) cartons, as well as small portion cups for coffee. US recipes therefore tend to measure it in cups and tablespoons rather than millilitres.

Labelled by fat percentage (Canada)

Canadian cartons are commonly labelled 10% cream alongside or instead of the name half-and-half, and 18% table cream sits next to it as a richer option. Reading the percentage on the carton is the quickest way to pick the right product.

Half cream is less common than single cream (United Kingdom)

UK half cream has at least 12% fat but is harder to find than single cream, which has at least 18%. If you make your own with double cream, which is much richer than Australian thickened cream, use a little more milk to avoid an overly rich blend.

Applies to Australia

Cream strength changes the home blend (Australia, United States, United Kingdom)

The three-to-one milk-and-cream mix assumes cream of about 35–36% fat, such as Australian thickened cream or US heavy cream. Australian thickened cream also contains gelatine or vegetable gum, which can give a slightly firmer texture than pure cream.

Where to buy it

Applies to Australia

Australia · hard to find

dairy fridge

It is rarely stocked, so buy full-cream milk and thickened or pure cream and mix your own.

New Zealand · hard to find

dairy fridge

It is not a common product, so mix standard milk with cream instead.

United Kingdom · moderate to find

dairy fridge

Look for half cream beside the single and double cream, though not every store carries it.

United States · easy to find

dairy fridge

Check the label so you do not pick up fat-free half-and-half or a flavoured coffee creamer by mistake.

Canada · easy to find

dairy fridge

It is usually labelled half-and-half or 10% cream and sits next to the 18% table cream.

What is Half-And-Half called in other countries?

Australia	half-and-half
United Kingdom	half cream
New Zealand	half-and-half
United States	half-and-half
Canada	half-and-half

half and halfhalf & half10% cream

Measurements differ too, not just names: the kitchen conversion chart covers cups, spoons and oven temperatures across these countries.

Questions people ask

Can you buy half-and-half in Australia?

Usually not, because Australian supermarkets rarely stock it as a separate product. Mix 185 ml full-cream milk with 65 ml thickened cream to make 250 ml, which lands at about the same fat level as US half-and-half.

Is half-and-half the same as light cream?

No, light cream has more fat than half-and-half. In the US, light cream carries at least 18% fat while half-and-half is usually about 10.5–12%, so light cream gives a slightly richer, thicker result when swapped in at the same volume.

Is half-and-half the same as coffee creamer?

No, half-and-half is simply milk and cream, while many US coffee creamers are non-dairy products made from vegetable oil, sugar and flavourings. Creamer is often sweetened and flavoured, so it is not a good stand-in for half-and-half in savoury cooking.

Can you whip half-and-half?

No, half-and-half has far too little fat to trap air and hold peaks. For whipped cream you need cream with at least 35% fat, such as Australian thickened cream or US heavy cream.

How much half-and-half is a tablespoon for coffee?

A US tablespoon of half-and-half is 15 ml, but an Australian tablespoon is 20 ml. If you are following a US recipe with an Australian tablespoon you will add a third more than intended, which matters more in baking than in a cup of coffee.

Can I use half-and-half instead of milk?

Yes, you can use it in place of full-cream milk at the same volume. The result will be richer and slightly thicker, and sauces will be less likely to curdle, but cakes and batters may turn out a little denser and more tender.

Where Half-And-Half comes from

Half-and-half takes its name from being a blend of milk and cream. It is pasteurised and homogenised so the cream stays evenly mixed through the milk instead of rising to the top.

Half-And-Half is usually gluten-free, nut-free — check the label, and see the disclaimer.